My new book, The Silence Tax: How Leaders Drive Out Fear and Futility, comes out February 9, 2027. Pre-order now

Wrong-Side Surgery and the Pressure to Cover It Up: A Patient Safety Failure

TL;DR: Wrong-side surgery is a system failure, not just human error. Fear, silence, and lack of psychological safety allow mistakes to be hidden–making repeat harm more likely.

I don't post every episode of the My Favorite Mistake podcast here, but my latest episode (#70) will have a strong appeal to readers of this blog.

This episode features Dr. David Mayer, who is an anesthesiologist and, among other things, the CEO of the Patient Safety Movement Foundation.

Click the image below for the episode page, where you can watch, listen, or read a transcript:

Wrong-Side Surgery Is a System Failure, Not Just Human Error

In the episode, Dr. Mayer tells a story from his residency about a surgeon cutting into the wrong side of a patient. That's human error — rather than demonizing that surgeon, we should think about the role of processes and systems and how we can error-proof or prevent that from even being possible.

Why Wrong-Side Surgeries Still Happen Today

This type of error (what I call a “so-called never event”) still happens today, as we saw in the news recently, from Austria:

Man has wrong leg amputated in ‘tragic' hospital mix-up

“A disastrous combination of circumstances led to the patient's right leg being amputated instead of his left,” the hospital's statement said.

Another article about this case said:

“The error appears to have been made shortly before the operation, when the leg that was to be amputated was marked, the clinic said.”

Why Wrong-Side Surgeries Still Happen Today

Marking the surgical site is only effective if the process can ensure that the wrong side / site cannot be marked incorrectly.

The hospital:

“…was investigating what happened and would review its standards.”

Did they have insufficient standards, or were the standards not being followed?

So anyway, back to the episode with Dr. Mayer. The human error on the part of the surgeon was compounded by the CHOICE to lie to the patient about what happened. That deliberate action is far worse and would probably merit punishment if the lie were discovered by hospital leadership.

Fear, Hierarchy, and the Silence That Follows Mistakes

I don't blame Dr. Mayer for not speaking up. He was a resident, therefore low in the hierarchy. If there wasn't a culture of “psychological safety” that would have allowed him to speak up, I understand why he kept quiet in the moment.

But, I appreciate how Dr. Mayer was inspired by that incident — it's led him to do a lot of good in his career, working to improve systems and cultures in organizations.

Why This Still Matters in 2026: Psychological Safety Saves Lives

Back to the surgeon… maybe there were extenuating circumstances that led to fatigue or being rushed. Maybe the surgeon didn't have the psychological safety to admit the error. Admitting the error, as tragic as it might be, allows us to then work together to improve the system so it cannot happen again.

Cover-Ups Prevent Learning — and Guarantee Repeat Harm

Hiding, denying, or covering up the mistake means it's going to happen again, to somebody else.

What do you think? Do you have experiences like Dr. Mayer's?

I thank Dr. Mayer for having the discussion in this episode.

Cover of The Mistakes That Make Us: Cultivating a Culture of Learning and Innovation by Mark Graban

Make it safe to learn from mistakes

In The Mistakes That Make Us: Cultivating a Culture of Learning and Innovation, I share stories and practical steps for leaders who want people to admit mistakes, learn from them, and prevent them from happening again. It received the 2025 Shingo Publication Award.

Read a free previewSee buying options

Get New Posts Sent To You

Choose your emails:
Mark Graban
Mark Graban

Mark Graban helps leaders build workplaces where people speak up and improvement sticks, through Lean management, psychological safety, and better use of metrics. He is a keynote speaker, advisor, and host of the Lean Blog Interviews and My Favorite Mistake podcasts.

He is the author of The Mistakes That Make Us, Measures of Success, Lean Hospitals, and Healthcare Kaizen, and a three-time recipient of the Shingo Publication Award. His next book is The Silence Tax.

Mark is also a Senior Advisor to KaiNexus. Get his free ebooks.

Articles: 6500

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *