Signs are Better Than an Email: Condo Trash Chute Edition

389
2

I often write and speak about how warning signs (or cautions) are not effective at preventing mistakes, errors, and problems. See this recent post about this: Signs Are Not Mistake-Proofing: Hospital Hallways Edition.

And to prove that I've been writing about this for a long time, here's a post from 2007: Signs are Not Error Proofing: Electrical Circuit Breaker Edition.

By the way, the words “mistake” and “error” are synonyms to me. And Prof. John Grout, an expert on this topic agrees (or he convinced me that the meanings are the same).

Signs, generally, are an ineffective attempt at mistake-proofing (or poka-yoke in Japanese). When we see signs in a workplace that say things like:

  • Warning
  • Caution
  • Watch out
  • Please remember
  • Don't forget
  • Danger

Those signs are all screaming out to us as an opportunity to try something that's more effective. Signs can be ignored. It's better to change the process or the system (including the equipment or software) so that it's easier to do the right thing and harder (if not impossible) to do the wrong thing.

That said, sometimes a sign is the best you can do (or the best you've figured out to do… for now).

One example of mistake-proofing that's better than a sign can be found at In-N-Out (and other fast food / quick service restaurants), as I blogged about here:

The photo is of the food, but the main point was the difference between a trash can (at other restaurants) that has a sign that yells at you about not throwing out trays or baskets, like this:

In-N-Out has a trash area where the trash holes (is that the technical term?) are big enough for things they WANT you to throw out (like disposable cups) while being too small for their trays to fit:

Mistake-proofing (the smaller hole) is FAR more effective than the warning sign.

Our Condo Trash Situation

My wife and I live in a high-rise condo and there is a trash chute in a small room that's just off the common-area hallway outside our unit.

We received an email on Sunday, at about 8 am, from the front desk security guard that read, in part:

“We are currently having an issue with the trash chute, it is not properly connected to the dumpster, and I would like to ask you to please hold off on using the trash chute until tomorrow (Monday, the 18th) as much as possible so we can get things fixed. Thank you.”

The maintenance manager comes in on Monday morning. It wasn't worth him making a separate trip to the building on a Sunday.

Later that day, probably after dinner, out of habit I:

  • Noticed the trash was full
  • Grabbed the bag
  • Carried it to the trash room
  • Dropped it down the chute

“Oh no!”

That was my immediate reaction. The bag was barely off the end of my finger tips, but it was too late.

I had forgotten about that request to please not use the trash chute until Monday morning.

My Suggestion… For Next Time

Here's what it would have looked like if they had put a SIGN on / over the trash chute handle would have been a “point of use” reminder. It wouldn't have relied on my memory. I bet I'm not the only one who forgot. The sign being over the trash chute door handle would have been impossible to miss. Unless you taped the door shut, the sign isn't perfect mistake proofing.

But I think it would have been better than an email. Again, I wish I had thought of this Sunday morning.

If the sign had been placed NEAR the trash chute (as I also simulated here on Tuesday, shown in the photo below), it might have been easily missed by somebody who was moving on autopilot. If you're doing this all the time, you're probably going off of muscle memory as you are using your full cognitive powers.

I think the existing sign on the door says “No boxes” — in a way that's language-neutral. My sign is admittedly not. The sign above is quite wordy, but it's good to have those rules posted for handy reference instead of having to find the “rules and regulations” document online.

Maybe a better sign for the “don't use the trash chute today” purpose would have been a red circle / slash that implies “DO NOT USE” that could have been placed over the handle.

Even though my sign is only in English, I think it gets a “plus” for trying to explain WHY this directive of “do not use” was being given and how long it would be in effect.

Here's a blog post about explaining why that's a story from my 2005 visit to the NUMMI plant:

Having a sign would have also avoided the “failure mode” of people not checking their email on Sunday (I know, I should take a break from peeking at my phone).

Now, somebody would have had to print out a sign for each floor in the building. I would have been happy to help out with that… had I thought of it. But I didn't.

Next time.

Conclusion: Mistake proofing is better than a point of use information sign. But a sign is better than an email or a memo.

What was the Root Cause of the Problem?

There's also, perhaps, a root cause to the problem of “trash chute is not properly connected to the dumpster.”

I wouldn't ask, “Who screwed that up?”

I'd ask questions like, “How did that occur?” and “What can we do to prevent that?” Why did that happen?

It could be an opportunity for a “5 Whys” analysis (although I tend to call that the “Many Whys,” as I've blogged about here:


What do you think? Please scroll down (or click) to post a comment. Or please share the post with your thoughts on LinkedIn – and follow me or connect with me there.

Did you like this post? Make sure you don't miss a post or podcast — Subscribe to get notified about posts via email daily or weekly.


Check out my latest book, The Mistakes That Make Us: Cultivating a Culture of Learning and Innovation:

Get New Posts Sent To You

Select list(s):
Previous articleOscars Ratings Up for Third Year in a Row. True, but What’s the Context??
Next articleRyan McCormack’s Operational Excellence Mixtape: March 22, 2024
Mark Graban
Mark Graban is an internationally-recognized consultant, author, and professional speaker, and podcaster with experience in healthcare, manufacturing, and startups. Mark's new book is The Mistakes That Make Us: Cultivating a Culture of Learning and Innovation. He is also the author of Measures of Success: React Less, Lead Better, Improve More, the Shingo Award-winning books Lean Hospitals and Healthcare Kaizen, and the anthology Practicing Lean. Mark is also a Senior Advisor to the technology company KaiNexus.

2 COMMENTS

  1. There was another problem with the trash chute — the next Sunday.

    The front desk team graciously accepted my suggestion to post signs on each floor.

    I guess the next question would be the root cause of the trash chute problem… maybe I can help with the problem solving…

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.