For Real Improvement, You Need Honesty & Transparency, Not Anonymity
This announcement caught my eye recently: “New site lets you tell your boss anything, anonymously.”
A startup's website allows you to send anonymous ideas or feedback, “the modern age's equivalent of the old suggestion box.”
In my opinion, this is automating or digitizing the wrong model for improvement… I wonder how much improvement you will really get if this is the main channel of communication? One reason suggestion boxes are dysfunctional are that they, as one hospital employee said once, “attract anonymous complaints about other people.”
This is one reason given for why suggestion boxes always have locks – the anonymous complaints become an H.R. issue, where confidentiality is key.
We can do better than anonymous complaints.
One hospital lab that's featured in my book, Healthcare Kaizen, found that when they moved to a transparent and visual idea board system, that they discussion changed from anonymous complaints to constructive feedback and ideas for improvement.
If your organization is using TellYourBossAnything.com, it might be a symptom of a deeper organizational problem… the inability to give frank feedback is a problem (giving frank feedback is called “candor with respect” at the great Lean health system, ThedaCare).
Or, the problem is that managers don't receive feedback or ideas in a constructive way.
Or, nothing constructive comes from those ideas. An anonymous website seems like a workaround to that problem. What is the root cause of the problem that prevents you from being open and honest with your boss?
The TYBA website says their approach is meant to be “helpful” and not just anonymous. They promise respectful interactions and users getting banned if they say things that are inappropriate.
Transparency is one guiding principle of KaiNexus, a software startup that I'm on the management team of.
Our KaiNexus process:
- Employee enters a problem (and possibly a proposed solution) into KaiNexus (via the web or their iPhone)
- Their leader (I hate the word “boss”) is notified of the “opportunity for improvement” along with the person's name
- The idea is quickly acknowledged and it's discussed face to face or via KaiNexus as the communication platform
- Once the idea has been assigned (often times back to the person who had the idea), then the problem, any ideas, and the progress of implementation is visible to EVERYBODY in the organization
- Long story short, problems get resolved and everybody is kept in the loop.
If there were something completely inappropriate entered into KaiNexus, it can be deleted before that transparency is created. KaiNexus is not a system for telling your boss that he has bad breath or that she was mean to you in a meeting yesterday. It's about constructive process improvements… so there's nothing to hide or keep secret.
Involving the manager isn't a bureaucratic or controlling part of the process… it's keeping with good Kaizen principles that managers or leaders should collaborate with their employees… not just say “yes” or “no” to ideas, as you might have in a suggestion box program.
KaiNexus believes strongly that transparency and visibility are the keys to collaboration and improvement. Just because you CAN keep things anonymous with technology doesn't mean that you should.
What do you think — and you can leave anonymous comments, if you want. :-) Tell you blogger anything!