By November 22, 2015 10 Comments Read More →

Famed NBC Video with Dr. Deming from 1980 Now Available: “If Japan Can, Why Can’t We?”

Anybody who has studied the work and writings of W. Edwards Deming knows the part of his bio and story that says (per Wikipedia):

“In 1980, he was featured prominently in an NBC TV documentary titled If Japan can… Why can’t we? about the increasing industrial competition the United States was facing from Japan. As a result of the broadcast, demand for his services increased dramatically, and Deming continued consulting for industry throughout the world until his death at the age of 93.”

Screen Shot 2015-11-21 at 8.26.49 AMI’ve never been able to see this program. I was six years old at the time and my summertime activities didn’t include watching long-form NBC documentaries. The video has never been available online… until now.

Screen Shot 2015-11-20 at 5.26.47 PMThe W. Edwards Deming Institute and Dr. Deming’s grandson Kevin Cahill worked with NBC to make the program available, giving the institute perpetual rights to it (see their blog post). To the institute’s credit, they’ve made this freely available on YouTube.

Here is the video, which runs about 76 minutes:

I’ll write another blog post (probably multiple blog posts) about the video, its highlights, and my reflections.

There’s great interest in this video, gauging from reaction on Twitter and LinkedIn after I shared it there.

I’d encourage you to watch it, not just out of historical curiosity, but to think about how this video and story is relevant today, 35 years later.

The main segment on Dr. Deming is Part IV of the program (one hour in), which you can reach via this direct link. Dr. Deming also makes a few brief appearances earlier in the documentary.

A few highlights and images I shared:

What do you think? Please post a comment and share the video.


Thanks for reading! I’d love to hear your thoughts. Please scroll down to post a comment. Click here to receive posts via email.


Now Available – The updated, expanded, and revised 3rd Edition of Mark Graban’s Shingo Research Award-Winning Book Lean Hospitals: Improving Quality, Patient Safety, and Employee Engagement. You can buy the book today, including signed copies from the author.

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...
Please consider leaving a comment or sharing this post via social media.

Mark Graban's passion is creating a better, safer, more cost effective healthcare system for patients and better workplaces for all. Mark is a consultant, author, and speaker in the "Lean healthcare" methodology. He is author of the Shingo Award-winning books Lean Hospitals and Healthcare Kaizen, as well as The Executive Guide to Healthcare Kaizen. His most recent project is an eBook titled Practicing Lean that benefits the Louise H. Batz Patient Safety Foundation, where Mark is a board member. Mark is also the VP of Improvement & Innovation Services for the technology company KaiNexus.

10 Comments on "Famed NBC Video with Dr. Deming from 1980 Now Available: “If Japan Can, Why Can’t We?”"

Trackback | Comments RSS Feed

  1. Robert says:

    A lot of interesting information. I was curious about how the steel mill focused on the incentives for workers to produce more (the Japanese visitors commented on the plant being the most productive they had seen, according to the manager), but I didn’t hear a lot about the quality of that production. I presume it was high productivity coupled with high quality. For those who feel like we are living in unique times, an objective assessment of the video will show that we face the same challenges now that were faced (and, in some cases, addressed) in the past.

    • Mark Graban
      Twitter:
      says:

      Thanks for the comment, Robert.

      There’s much more to blog about… a few things that stood out were the practices highlighted in the video that Dr. Deming quite likely would have criticized strongly.

      1) The production quantity-based incentive pay at Nucor… did that have a negative effect on quality or teamwork? Piecework type pay systems often do. Maybe Nucor had a good process that only allowed for (or paid for) the production of high quality steel.

      2) The quality posters and slogans at Nashua Corp (which is surprising since Dr. Deming worked directly with them and Bill Conway). I guess the habits of communicating through posters and slogans die hard?

      This chart, with a 10-year running average DOES suggest productivity growth bottomed out in 1980 and got better. How much of that was due to information technology, as opposed to employee engagement and management systems? Probably mostly IT?

      I would want to do some research on healthcare productivity – depending on how that’s measured?
      Mark Graban recently posted..Maybe We Should Call it “The Many Whys” Instead of “The Five Whys” in #Lean & #LeanStartupMy Profile

  2. Nathan says:

    More than half of the discussion focuses on updating technology and relaxing government regulations as the solution to productivity problems. That still hasn’t changed as most companies are just looking for that ‘magic pill’ of new equipment, software, or other tech to fix all the problems. Also disappointing is the implication that productivity gains can only be made in manufacturing but service industries and government are exempt.

    As one relatively short on life experience it’s depressing to see how little the attitude of North American industry has changed since even before I was born.

    • Mark Graban
      Twitter:
      says:

      The hairstyles and technology has changed… but sometimes it seems not much else has.

      Bill Conway, CEO of Nashua Corp. said in the video:

      “Anyone who doesn’t join that [3rd industrial] revolution [led by Deming] is, I think, over time going to be in serious trouble.”

      That didn’t turn out to be true in most industries, did it? Some organizations that didn’t adopt Deming’s ideas are in serious trouble… but many are doing just fine in spite of that.

      Deming’s revolution petered out…
      Mark Graban recently posted..Please Give Input on Locations for My Workshops in 2016My Profile

  3. I, too, find the comment about Nucor’s incentives interesting. I wonder if they still incentivize this way? If not, why not? If so, are they paying for what should be produced by the “system” anyway? You can’t get 2 gallons of milk from a one gallon jug.

    If the system is set up to produce X and you are getting 1.X+ by offering incentives, then it may be that incorrect data may have been used to establish production quotas in the first place. This is no indictment on management or labor, just would like to know more as I’ve seen first hand how incentives KILL quality and morale while driving internal competition.

    • Mark Graban
      Twitter:
      says:

      It sounded like, in the program, that incentive pay was very individualized.

      I found this page about Nucor and it sounds more like profit-sharing — total profits divided by number of employees.

      Group incentives can be gamed, but it’s less dysfunctional that individual piecework pay?

      When I got to visit some distilleries and cooperages (that make barrels) in Scotland, one was on a pure piecework system, where employees were paid by the barrel. They were paid by the GOOD barrel, which was based on a quality control inspector’s assessment. I saw what looked like arguing over the quality level…

      The second cooperage paid an hourly rate.

      Interesting to see what difference in approach.

      I agree with your comment that internal competition can be very dysfunctional and can hurt quality and performance.
      Mark Graban recently posted..Please Give Input on Locations for My Workshops in 2016My Profile

      • Mark, I also found this article on Nucor’s hourly pay system. http://www.businessknowhow.com/manage/nucor.htm

        They pay a below average wage with penalties (if you miss a day of work you don’t get your bonus for the week).

        A key point of systems thinking is, to quote Deming, “the system is the method by which we produce results.” And, I believe that. If Nucor’s “system” is capable of producing 35-40 tones of steel per hour when a bonus is paid, then why can’t they produce that when a bonus isn’t paid? Nucor leadership knows what the system can produce! So does labor. This is nothing more than shuffling checkers on a board.

        On another note, I do believe in sharing “revenue”, but I’ll save that for another discussion!

  4. Mark Graban
    Twitter:
    says:

    My friend Dan Markovitz beat me to the punch in blogging about this powerful moment from the video:

    I WANT TO BE A SOMEBODY.

    Yes, the notion of respect for each individual of critically important to Lean and I think Dr. Deming’s influence on Toyota played a part in that.
    Mark Graban recently posted..Giving Thanks for Lean, Kaizen, and Improvement (& A New Chapter from Paul Akers)My Profile

Post a Comment

CommentLuv badge