I have a funny story from earlier this week. I was doing some process observation with nurses at a hospital, helping them identify waste and possible Lean improvements. We entered a room and the nurse introduced me quickly to the patient. I was carrying my notepad, but no stopwatch or anything.
The elderly lady says, “So you’re the Time Study man…” with a smile. I thought, wow what a wonderful antiquated term. It’s the stereotype of the industrial engineer. When I changed my major to I.E., my dad’s friend (an Electrical Engineer, like my dad), asked how my stopwatch training was coming along.
As this old 1950’s article from Time Magazine (amazingly available online) describes, the Time Study Man wasn’t exactly a friend of the workers. Time studies, in a traditional sense, were very Taylorist in nature. The educated engineer stands over the working man, timing him and thinking of ways to “speed him up” (sorry for the non-inclusive gender terms, this is the 1950’s after all). It was a conflict between worker and management, with the Time Study Man caught i the middle.
Of course, the Lean approach is different. This is about partnering up with employees to identify waste. Making their job easier also helps improve service and care for the patients. In the context of a “No Layoffs Due to Lean” promise, finding improvements isn’t going to lead to job losses. Instead, it frees up time to do a good job and to spend more time with patients, instead of being rushed. Lean isn’t only about doing the value added work faster, it’s about reducing non value added work and eliminating delays.
So, as I described briefly, with a smile, “Well, sort of… but we’re working together to find ways to provide you better care.” Was it awkward to have me following along? Sure, somewhat. But, management had done a very good job of explaining what this was about and what it wasn’t. It’s not about nurses running faster. It’s about avoiding the need to walk (or run) by improving the process and eliminating all of the types of waste (which are present in the hospital workplace, to be sure).
Such things were known, even in the 1950’s, as the Time article says:
“Such cooperation is the best evidence that the time study creates few problems if the company uses competent technicians who carefully and repeatedly explain what they are doing, and include in any job evaluation such human factors as fatigue and boredom. An atmosphere of good labor relations is also a big help; although the International Union of Electrical Workers refused to permit Westinghouse’s time study, it raised no objection to a similar study at G.E. Where a union suspects that the time study is being used by management to cut pay or fire workers, the stopwatch will always make trouble. But properly used, the time study is a tool that can not only cut costs and hike production, but boost both workers’ wages and company profits.”
Thanks for reading! I’d love to hear your thoughts. Please scroll down to post a comment. Click here to be notified about posts via email. Learn more about Mark Graban’s speaking, writing, and consulting.