Hand Sanitizer Dispensers: Fancy & Electronic vs. Simple & Manual
First off, I want to briefly acknowledge the Ukranians' fight for freedom and sovereignty in the face of the Putin invasion. It seems that many, many Russians don't support the aggression, so I hesitate to call it a “Russian invasion.” I have family in Slovakia, even though my direct ancestors came to America in my great-grandparents' generation.
I'm empathetic to the plight of former Soviet-bloc countries that want to remain free and independent. Of course, the combined nation of Czechoslovakia was invaded by the Soviets and others in 1968, before I was born. China condemned that attack, along with Western nations. China has been silent on Ukraine.
It's about the smallest possible gesture, but I've changed the blog logo to include a Ukrainian flag. For what it's worth, I support you and I condemn in no uncertain terms what Putin has done. I hope peace and freedom can be restored to Ukraine quickly and that no other nations are threatened or invaded.
Let's Talk About Hand Sanitizer
OK, on a decidedly lighter note, I think I'm obsessed with hand sanitizer dispensers — especially in hospitals and other public places.
I've written before about my concept for a “two-bin hand sanitizer dispenser” that (when combined with better replenishment processes) would prevent empty dispensers from being found on the wall in hospitals.
It's a solvable problem, for sure — if we'd put our minds to it.
Look at how we've solved (or tried to solve) the problem of “running out of toilet paper”:
You can see where my two-bin hand sanitizer idea comes from.
Problems With the Fancy Dispensers
There's the problem of empty dispensers. There are also related problems that lead to the same functional problem of “no hand sanitizer where it's needed”:
- Battery-powered dispensers that have dead batteries
- Proprietary hand sanitizer refills that lock you in to using only one type of bag / container
I'm generalizing, but in the U.S., we LOVE solutions that are fancy and high-tech. Here's a photo of two dispensers (from two different makers) that were side by side in a facility I saw recently:
With “single-bin dispensers” like this, you have to either replace the container before it's empty (leading to some wasted product) or you wait until it's already empty (which drives the waste of not having sanitizer when and where it's needed, which can lead to higher infection rates).
These days, most hand sanitizers seem to be driven by sensors and battery power to squirt out a certain amount of product. I don't have precise data on this, but it seems like the “press to pump” dispensers have fallen out of favor compared to the “automatic” ones.
Maybe there's a concern expressed about touching a dispenser handle / button / pump that others have touched. But, if we're immediately using hand sanitizer, doesn't that solve the problem?
What problem is the battery-powered dispenser intended to solve?
It “solves” one problem (that might not even be a problem) but it creates a new problem because the dispenser is useless with a dead battery (and I've run into this). There's no apparent “manual pump backup plan” option.
The Elegant Foot-Pump Dispenser
Last November, I had a chance to take a vacation with family to France — a trip that had been delayed a year by the Covid pandemic and a trip that found us learning that the Omicron variant was a thing about two days before coming home.
In France, I saw many hand sanitizer dispensers that were driven by manual foot pumps. Brilliant! Or I should say, “brillant” or “brillante” or “magnifique”!
Here is one from a hotel lobby:
It's not as “fancy” but, to me, it seems more “elegant.” It's easy to use. You won't have to worry about your hand touching the button or pump handle. It seems like you could replace it with many different non-proprietary dispenser bottles, as long as they worked with a manual pump action.
Now, these would be challenging for a person who is in a wheelchair, for example, but how many of the automated dispensers might be too high on the wall for somebody to easily reach? Does a floor standing pump get in the way or run the risk of getting tipped over in a way that the wall-mounted dispenser avoids?
For comparison, here is a floor standing dispenser (here in the U.S.) that's battery powered / automatic, below:
What About Price and Cost to Operate?
Are these foot pump dispensers less expensive? Do they last longer? I'd guess the answer is “yes” to both, but I'm not sure.
Wait, let's search Amazon. You can buy anything there.
The list price for a Purell automated wall-mounted dispenser is… $50. You can buy one on Amazon now for just $22.54. But, it says The “refills sold separately.” Is the dispenser artificially cheap because they have a “razors and blades” business model?
You can buy two 1200 mL containers of Purell for $32. that's about $26.67 per liter.
The foot pump one is a “Universal Bottle Fit” so can we get cheaper non-proprietary bottles? You can use any size from 250 mL to 1 liter.
You can buy a one-liter bottle of Purell for $20 and that's without shopping around.
If you're using a lot of hand sanitizer, the foot pump dispenser pays for itself pretty quickly.
What do you think? Should we be using the clever, less-complicated foot pump solution? Is that what a traditional “Lean sensei” would tell us to do? Does that matter? Am I overthinking something that's just not that important?What do you think? Scroll down to comment or share your thoughts and the post on social media. Don't want to miss a post or podcast? Subscribe to get notified about posts via email daily or weekly.
- Oops! Another Mistake During a Webinar About Mistakes - September 30, 2022
- Damon Baker on Lean, Private Equity, and the Ownership Works Initiative - September 28, 2022
- Reading About Lean at GE in Italy Makes Me Hungry for Pizza, While Savoring Employee Empowerment - September 27, 2022