If you have to add a warning or instruction label to something that should be obvious in its use, then the item is probably badly designed. I think that’s a pretty good design principle for products or software. Slapping on a label after the fact is a workaround, at best.
I’ve found a few recent examples of that principle in my travels.
First is from the North American International Auto Show (which I also blogged about here).
The BMW display, beyond the cool cars and the apparent 5S markings, had a step that many people kept tripping over, even with a warning sign.
The white step down onto a white surface… from the top of the step, people couldn’t really see that light. So about half of the people tripped, even with the warning sign. It goes to show a warning sign can’t make up for bad (yet beautiful) design.
The second example was from a Hampton Inn that I stayed at. The mirrored closet door looks completely symmetrical and you wouldn’t know what side to pull on.
Tacking on the “OPEN THIS SIDE” decal is a sign that the door wasn’t designed well. They could have had some sort of handle that indicated which side to open.
Why does this stuff matter? Am I just being a nit-picky grouch? I think it matters when we think about the workplace and poor human factors. Have we designed a workplace that’s visual and obvious to employees, making it easy for them to do the right things the right way… or are we slapping up a bunch of warnings and labels as a workaround?
Last example was from a hospital cafeteria. It sure looks like a trash can…
It was really unclear what this was if it was not a trash can. It was near the area where you return cafeteria trays. There was no alternative to the trash can, I mean no alternative to the “non-trash can.” The sign seems to be a indicator of a design problem, the problem being that it’s reasonable for people to assume it’s a trash can because, well, it looks like one. It is one.
I have a collection of silly workplace warnings at my sister site www.BeMoreCareful.com… as the site description says, these “be carefuls!” rarely get to the root cause of any issue. The sign is a symptom of a problem. The sign is generally not an effective countermeasure.
The sign says don’t trip… people trip and fall. A sign says “pull here” and the hotel guest pulls first on the wrong side (yes, that happened). A sign says “don’t throw trash here” and there’s probably always trash there anyway… don’t blame the people, blame the system.
Thanks for reading! I’d love to hear your thoughts. Please scroll down to post a comment. Click here to be notified about posts via email. Learn more about Mark Graban’s speaking, writing, and consulting.