Former House Speaker Newt Gingrich, with the help of Michael George, tried injecting talk of so-called “Lean Six Sigma” into the 2012 presidential race, but I think it was received as a bit of a novelty topic that illustrated the relative quirkiness of Gingrich.
The state of Washington has been working to apply Lean principles under the leadership of current governor Chris Gregoire (D), who is not running in 2012. The issue of Lean actually came up in the debates and was fact checked by the Seattle Times: “Truth Needle: A look at Inslee’s ‘lean management’ claim.”
The Democrat candidate, Jay Inslee, said:
“There is no reason on this green Earth that we have not embraced the efficiency measures in state government that have been so successful in private enterprise,” said Inslee, adding “these have not been used under any predecessor, Republican or Democrat.
Wait, but wasn’t Washington already using Lean? Why is the Democrat candidate apparently criticizing the current governor of his own party?
“his campaign has since said that Inslee meant to say that previous governors have never fully embraced the practice.”
That’s actually a pretty nuanced discussion of Lean in an election cycle. When we talk about private companies or hospitals, to say they “haven’t fully embraced” Lean might mean that they are just using an isolated tool or two (like 5S or value stream mapping) or that Lean is just a bunch of projects instead of a new way of thinking.
What has Washington done with Lean?
“Perhaps recognizing these successes, Washington state government has been exploring lean since at least 2007. That year, the Department of Corrections implemented lean in its prisoner work program.
Other state agencies have followed suit in fits and starts.
One of the most talked-about examples is the Department of Social and Health Services (DSHS). It reduced the average wait time for eligibility interviews for public-assistance applicants from four weeks to 45 minutes or less, and cut processing time for those applications from about two weeks to a week or less.”
Gov. Gregiore issued a mandate that all executive cabinet agencies would, by August 31, 2012, complete a Lean project. At best, that’s a way of kickstarting the use of Lean, although I’m not a big fan of blanket mandates like that. If a leader, in any type of organization, is mandated to Lean (and they aren’t intrinsically motivated or passionate about Lean), you tend to get trivial projects where the results are likely not sustained.
A state rep “mocked” this approach as “dabbling” with Lean, that the governor has “not embraced it at all” and that it’s a “fake program.”
He might be right. But, sometimes you have to start somewhere. Starting with projects can often lead to wholesale cultural transformation, as we’ve seen at ThedaCare and Virginia Mason Medical Center (in Seattle, and they are now coaching the state on Lean, after learning it from formerly-Seattle based Boeing).
As the Times writer said:
Ultimately, analyzing the strength of Gregoire’s embrace of lean is a subjective exercise.
That’s true. But, I’m encouraged that Washington is taking action and making progress. It sounds like, no matter which way the election turns, that Lean will continue to be a part of Washington’s future. The Democrat clearly wants it and the Republican candidate, Rob McKenna (supported by local Lean advocate Paul Akers, who made Lean a center piece of his U.S. Senate primary run) wants Lean as well (see this video).
I wish Texas would start pursuing similar strategies, at least in a more public way (if Lean is being used in our state government today).
About LeanBlog.org: Mark Graban is a consultant, author, and speaker in the “lean healthcare” methodology. Mark is author of the Shingo Award-winning books Lean Hospitals and Healthcare Kaizen, as well as the new Executive Guide to Healthcare Kaizen. Mark is also the VP of Innovation and Improvement Services for KaiNexus.