Today’s post is a case study submitted by Abdul N. Mansour, Director Lean & Process Improvement at Scottsdale (AZ) Healthcare. The material here and the PDF downloads are shared with his permission.
This project is a noteworthy story in that they were able to gain agreement of the anesthesiologists and staff across five sites and a total of 62 operating rooms, standardizing the carts for the sake of maximizing patient safety and reducing time spent searching for supplies. Click on the photo at left for a larger view of an “after” photo of standardized drawer.
It can often be tough to gain agreement and consensus on standardizing a single room or a single area used by a small team. Creating this across multiple sites is quite an impressive leadership and change management feat.
Here is the case study: Anesthesia cart article aug.3.2011 (PDF)
Here is a separate A3 document that’s embedded in the case: A3 Anesthesia Carts June 30.2011 (PDF)
Some highlights from the case study (direct quotes in italics):
An anesthesiologist commented before the project: “Every cart in every room in every site is set up differently and we always have to search for items, and there are always items in the carts that we rarely use.”
This searching can introduce unnecessary risks to patient care as well as frustration to the healthcare professionals.
Highlights of some of the approaches and Lean methods used:
- The 3 Actuals:
- 1) Talking to the actual people who work in the process,
- 2) visiting the actual places where the processes take place, and
- 3) observing the actual processes
- Process mapping the current processes by following the 7 types of flows: Patient, Provider, Medication, Supplies, Information, Equipment and Processes
- Identifying the eight types of waste: Over Processing, Correction, Inventory, Wait, Search, Space and Complexity
- Developing the A3: Figure 1
- 5S: Sort, Simplify, Sweep, Standardize and Sustain
- Measurement: Baseline data, post-implementation data and pictures before and after
- Spaghetti Diagram: Observing and recording the physical movements of staff when they want to retrieve medications and supplies
Feedback from an anesthesiologist after the improvements:
Joseph J. Sandor, MD, an anesthesiologist and medical director of Scottsdale Healthcare’s Piper Surgery Center said, “Standardization of the anesthesia carts, including Pyxis access for drug access in every operating room, is proving to save time and expense to the system. From the perspective of an anesthesiologist moving from one anesthetizing location to another within the hospital, the consistencies in the anesthesia machines and carts creates a significantly higher level of safety for the patients we are asked to provide anesthesia for.”
Some specific results of the anesthesia cart standardization project include:
- 80+ percent reductions in medication discrepancies between used and recorded
- Physician and staff satisfaction was very obvious, with reduced need to walk by an average of 50 miles per month.
- Anesthesia physicians and technicians are happy they don’t have to waste time looking in every drawer to find an item. These professionals were involved in determining the specific item to be stocked in specific drawers.
Please download and view the entire PDF document, which includes more details and lessons learned from the project, along with Abdul’s contact info.
You can also leave comments here if you’d like to discuss this work and these concepts and I expect that Abdul will participate in the discussion.
Thanks to Abdul for sharing this case studying and for publishing it here. I’ve talked to Abdul many times over the last two years or so and we finally met in person at the recent Lean Healthcare Transformation Summit.
Coincidentally, a visit to one of the Scottsdale Healthcare facilities, back in early 2004, was my very first personal exposure to Lean healthcare – in the emergency department. I wasn’t there as a patient, but rather as a “gemba visitor” as part of a local Phoenix-area Lean networking group. Some former Motorola employees had done that early work – either as employees or outside consultants, I don’t know for sure. But their work piqued my interest for what eventually became a move into healthcare.
Thanks for reading! I’d love to hear your thoughts. Please scroll down to post a comment. Click here to be notified about posts via email. Learn more about Mark Graban’s speaking, writing, and consulting.