Here’s a picture of the two drugs that were mixed up when the three babies were killed at the hospital in Indianapolis last week.
As the MD wrote in the letter-to-the-editor that I’ve linked to above, the deaths were absolutely preventable. We can’t just blame the drug maker. This was a systemic problem. The “system” killed the babies.
The packages, to me, are hardly “identical.” Similar yes, but not identical. The MD recommends that the manufacturer put the drugs in different sized bottles. That might be a decent step, and the extra cost to the manufacturer (stocking and producing different sized bottles) would be worth it.
Maybe stronger dosed drugs/pills should always be in larger bottles/packages, denoting “stronger.” That might increase the inventory costs throughout the supply chain (more space taken up by larger packaging), but pharmacies I’ve seen typically have their shelves somewhat lightly utilized, at least in one direction (e.g., the shelves are packed from left to right, but they’re not using vertical space well, or the shelves aren’t close enough together). Pharmacies are hardly efficiently “cubing out” their stock space the way a lean manufacturer might tweak their warehouse or truck utilization. If they were really concerned about that, they would use SQUARE or rectangular bottles (ala Fiji Water — look at how these bottles “cube out” nicely in boxes and shipping containers).
Anyway, this was a systemic problem with many root causes, all of which can be fixed using lean methods. The manufacturer — change the packaging (an error proofing method). The hospital needs to take steps — error proofing and standard work among the pharmacy techs and nurses to truly prevent the problems, not just to catch the problems in time or at the last minute before drugs are given to a patient.
I’ve read about how the hospital is putting in more “double checks.” This is just more inspection. We need more prevention. 100% inspection isn’t 100% effective. Having TWO people inspect anything (an engine built n a factory or drugs dispensed in a hospital) is sometimes WORSE than having one person inspect. Basic human psychology says we slack off if we think someone else will catch our mistake. Two inspectors might each think “well, the other person will catch it” and then nobody catches the problems.
Thanks for reading! I’d love to hear your thoughts. Please scroll down to post a comment. Click here to receive posts via email.
Now Available – The updated, expanded, and revised 3rd Edition of Mark Graban’s Shingo Research Award-Winning Book Lean Hospitals: Improving Quality, Patient Safety, and Employee Engagement. You can buy the book today, including signed copies from the author.